Data center study outlines opportunities to use Southwest Virginia’s assets for more sustainable operations
~ Study outlines existing advantages and makes recommendations for competitiveness ~
InvestSWVA today released the findings of a study into opportunities to attract and grow the data center industry in Southwest Virginia. The study, called Project Oasis, sought third-party validation for GO Virginia Region One to become a location of choice in the Commonwealth for data centers based on power and broadband infrastructure along with the use of geothermal cooling technology with the billions of gallons of water collected in underground mines as a significant energy and cost-savings tool.
“Southwest Virginia is primed to become the next hot spot for data centers,” said U.S. Senator Mark Warner. “This is a rapidly growing industry in Virginia and companies would be smart to consider GO Virginia Region One due to its land availability, ready workforce, and unique opportunities for sustainability and growth.”
“Reinventing our economy can include reusing our existing infrastructure,” said Congressman Morgan Griffith (R–VA9). “The water pooled in abandoned mine sites could serve industrial operations requiring substantial water use, such as data centers. This innovation would be a way to draw economic opportunities to Southwest Virginia. Just like the potential to use our abandoned mines for closed-loop hydropower, the possibilities presented by Project Oasis are exciting, and I stand ready to assist its progress to benefit our region.”
“Local, state and federal leaders have been working tirelessly to attract economic development to Southwest Virginia, and data centers are a hot topic as we look to bring more jobs here,” said Delegate Israel O’Quinn. “Data centers provide a unique opportunity to modernize our economy, bring 21st century jobs to our region, and leverage some of our strongest assets including land and sustainability.”
“Project Oasis provided an in-depth look at how we can attract data centers to Southwest Virginia, what we need to do in order to attract data centers, and the opportunities that could come by making some key investments in infrastructure,” said Will Payne, Managing Partner of Coalfield Strategies and project lead for InvestSWVA. “The study shows that Southwest Virginia is a prime location for data centers, particularly as the industry looks for location diversity.”
InvestSWVA, a public-private business attraction and marketing campaign for GO Virginia Region One, launched in 2019 under the umbrella of the Virginia Tobacco Region Revitalization Commission and backed by private industry. The initiative is co-chaired by Senator Ben Chafin, Delegate Terry Kilgore, Delegate Israel O’Quinn and Senator Todd Pillion. InvestSWVA has a strategic partnership with the Northern Virginia Technology Council.
The Project Oasis study found that Southwest Virginia is well-positioned for data centers because of land availability, geothermal cooling opportunities unique to the region, and workforce readiness and development. It also outlined policy and infrastructure changes that could be made by the region and state to make Southwest Virginia more attractive for data centers.
The study was led by R. Kent Hill, managing principal of On Point Development Strategies and the former manager of strategic economic development for Dominion Energy. The LENOWISCO Planning District Commission and the Southwest Virginia Energy Research and Development Authority served as strategic partners, while funding came from the GO Virginia Region One Council and the Virginia Department of Mines, Minerals and Energy.
Highlights from the study’s executive summary are below:
Economic Impact
The economic and fiscal impact analysis that was conducted for Project Oasis estimated that a large data center locating in the region would result in over 2,000 jobs created during construction, 40 direct and 59 additional permanent jobs, $233 million in economic activity during construction, and over $50 million in economic activity annually once operations begin.
Land and Geothermal Cooling
As data center suitable real estate becomes increasingly scarce and extremely expensive in Northern Virginia, other parts of the state with abundant power and fiber infrastructure have seen increased interest from data center developers.
Data centers have unique site and infrastructure requirements. There are multiple sites within GO Virginia Region One that could be suitable for a large data center. An assessment of available publicly controlled sites in the region of 25 acres or larger was conducted utilizing current data center industry site selection criteria.
Six sites met the general criteria for a large 36 MW hyperscale data center, and four additional sites could be suitable for a smaller data center of up to 10 MW. Two of the sites have opportunities for geothermal cooling through utilization of 51-degree mine water contained in vast pools below the surface of previously mined properties. An additional site has underground space that provides a consistent 55-degree temperature. Both conditions maximize water utilization and make data center operations more sustainable.
The annual savings for a geothermal cooling system would be over $1 million annually in reduced electric costs and municipal water purchases. Factoring in savings for avoided maintenance and other costs for a conventional system, the mine water system would provide a favorable return on investment and result in net annual savings for the data center operator. Coalfield Strategies, InvestSWVA’s project development team, is currently working on a pilot project with the Southwest Virginia Energy Research and Development Authority utilizing available grant funding that could be presented to data center companies with significant sustainability goals.
The region provides a low-risk option from natural and man-made disasters and meets distance requirements for disaster recovery and back up from primary data center locations such as Ashburn, Richmond, and Boydton, VA (Microsoft). The electric transmission network that supplies the region has three transmission providers and is electrically diverse from data center hubs in Northern Virginia, Richmond, and North Carolina.
Sustainability
Most new renewable energy projects for data centers in the current market utilize solar energy, which requires a large land area (6-10 acres per MW). Southwest Virginia has ample previously mined properties suitable for solar development.
The availability of solar development potential, cost-effective geothermal cooling, and the region’s desire to transform itself from a coal producing area to an innovative renewable energy hub, provides a compelling case for data centers who are increasingly mandating new facility locations that allow sustainability goals to be met.
Workforce
There is a reasonable pool of workers in the region with skills and training that are potentially transferrable to a data center environment. Wages for IT workers such as network architects and information security analysts are 17% less in GO Virginia Region One than the national average. Strong IT training programs and resources exist with the community colleges in the region and the University of Virginia at Wise.
State and Local Incentives
In addition to Virginia’s competitive statewide incentives, the Commonwealth allows a separate property tax rate to encourage investment (i.e. property tax on data center equipment). No localities in GO Virginia Region One currently have a data center specific taxation class. However, recent discussions with local government officials in the region have indicated there is a strong willingness to review tax structure for potential future changes that would make them more competitive. A tax rate and depreciation schedule that is competitive with localities such as Henrico County and Chesterfield County will be necessary to make the region a cost-effective alternative for this capital-intensive industry.
A Construction Employment Tax Credit of 20% of wages paid for construction workers for a data center or similar capital-intensive project located in underserved and rural areas should be evaluated.
